Peat Inn

Peat Inn, Cupar, near St Andrews, Fife, Scotland, KY15 5LH, United Kingdom

Back to search results

The Peat Inn is located within a tiny village of the same name about six miles from St Andrews. It is located within what was originally a 17th century coaching inn, and rose to culinary fame in 1984 when it first gained a Michelin star under David Wilson, which it retained on a somewhat erratic basis for many years, on and off. In 2006 the property changed hands and is now owned by Geoffrey Smeddle, who gained the Michelin star in 2010 and has retained it ever since.

The dining room is split into three sections, seating between 38 and 50 diners depending on the table configuration. There was an a la carte menu in addition to a tasting menu at £70, and a shorter fixed menu at £50. The room was carpeted with well-spaced tables covered in carefully ironed white tablecloths, the overall noise levels being moderate. The wine list included labels such as Chateau Pesquie Viognier 2015 at £30 for a bottle that you can find in the high street for £10, Zind Humbrecht Urban Pinot Gris 2005 at £73 compared to its retail price of £38, and Michelot Les Charrieres 2006 at £90 for a wine that will set you back £45 in the shops.

Bread was made from scratch in the kitchen, a choice of sourdough and slices of raisin and pumpkin seed bread. The latter was particularly good, with excellent flavour and texture (16/20). A pair of nibbles comprised courgette flan with red pepper and black olive, and a seaweed cracker with mussel mousse and sea purslane (15/20). A final nibble was a casserole of squid and watercress, a mix of finely diced and deep-fried  squid with a watercress sauce, which worked very well indeed (16/20).

Cured salmon with potato crust came with seared Orkney scallop, smoked halibut cream and keta (aka chum salmon or dog salmon). The fish was lightly cooked, the potatoes crisp, the scallop sweet and the dish enjoyable overall (16/20). Lobster came with cannelloni of mouli and a peanut sauce. This was particularly good, the shellfish tender and the sauce very effective, the flavour of the nuts coming through strongly; perhaps this sauce was an influence of the time the chef spent in Asia in his youth. The radish cannelloni provided an extra flavour note to balance the shellfish and the powerful sauce (17/20).

I tried an intermediate course of salsify "cannelloni" with venison ragu. The salsify, with its hint of oyster flavour when cooked, provided a base for a rich, dark sauce of the deer, and provided an interesting balance that worked effectively (16/20). For the main course, turbot was excellent, precisely cooked and served with tender langoustine tail, Jerusalem artichokes and romanesco (a kind of broccoli) with a thermidor sauce. The romanesco retained its texture well and provided an earthy balance to the seafood (16/20).

Wild roe deer was cooked pink and came on a bed of wilted watercress, with prunes and salt-baked celeriac, a purée of celeriac and pear, hazelnuts and an Armagnac sauce. The venison had good flavour and the accompaniments provided a good counterpoint to its richness, the earthy celeriac and the prunes and nuts proving to be effective complementary flavours (16/20).

Pear and apple croustillant came with caramel and an almond ice cream. The almonds in particular worked well, bringing their distinctive flavour and firm texture to contrast with the acidity of the fruit. The only issue that I had was with the croustillant cylinder itself, which was not really crisp (overall 15/20). Soufflé of mango and passion fruit was excellent, served with salted banana ice cream and warm pistachio madeleines. The soufflé itself was evenly cooked and light in texture, the acidity of the fruit working nicely with the madeleines (17/20). Coffee was from a supplier called Myrtle in Kircaldy, and the blend of arabica beams from Honduras, El Salvador and Uganda worked well, the overall result being rich and quite deep in flavour.

Service was charming, the waiters friendly and attentive. The bill came to £115 a head, with an excellent bottle of Bonny Doon Cigare Volant and some additional wine, if you stuck to a basic bottle then a typical cost per head might be around £100. I enjoyed this meal at Peat Inn very much, the menu appealing and interesting and the technical skill high, making the best of the lovely produce available in this part of the world. 


Add a comment


User comments

  • Jeffrey merrihue

    I have had many meals here over the years and they have all been very good...I was delighted to see the score you gave them...